"Uncle Derek Says"

Nidularium 'Leprosa'

Derek Butcher "In January 1999 Charles Dills was asked what a Nidularium 'Laparosa' looked like and put the question to Brom-l. This name sounded familiar to me because I had a similar question also from California in 1991 when I was conducting the Question and Answer segment in the Bromeliad Society Journal. Here I had been asked the differences between Nidularium rutilans, N. regelioides, and N. 'Leprosa'.

At that time the only difference I could find between the first two was that in N. rutilans the primary bracts are entire but lightly toothed in N.regelioides. Note that Elton Leme probably will be relegating N. regelioides to synonymy under N. rutilans when his book on Nidularium is published.
(*NOTE:The book on Nidularium by Elton Leme has now been published and regelioides is indeed a synonym of rutilans.)

Nidularium 'Leprosa' was a bit harder to find. It was not in "Bromelioideae" in Flora Neotropica (1979) nor was it in Padilla's "International Check List" (1979). The only reference was in Brian Smith's Manuscript of Bromeliad Hybrids and Cultivars (1984). Even the hybridist was unknown but the name persists! The parents were given as Nidularium regelioides and N. rosulatum.

Forever the doubting Thomas I wonder whether N. rosulatum was father. This plant is not common in collections and even Lyman B Smith confused it with N. fulgens at one time! Nidularium 'Leprosa' seems to have a limited area of circulation because it is only reported from California and has not been exported to Australia as far as I am aware. Could it be just a selfing of Nidularium regelioides? This is especially true if it does eventuate that this becomes included under Nidularium rutilans. We have certainly found in Australia that spotting on the leaves for N. rutilans can vary widely with the more heavily spotted being favoured. All the N.rutilans I have checked seem to be correctly named so I wonder whether the name of 'Leprosa' should have been given. I am hoping that this provocative statement will get some reaction so that we can find out what the true N. 'Leprosa' is known to all. A photograph would be fantastic. "


9-29-99
Here is a photo of Nidularium 'Leprosa' by Geoff Lawn

This was sent by Derek Butcher who says
"I still haven't had the chance to dissect one of these but I still think it is within regelioides/rutilans"
Nidularium 'Leprosa'

Send your comments and opinions to UncleDerekSays@fcbs.org
Your comments will be added to this page.

6-27-99
A comment from Geoff Johnson, Pineapple Place, Longwood,FL:
I'll make a note to send a photo of the plant I grow as Nid. 'Leprosa'. While your observations on the other plants (regelioides,rutilans) are no bone of contention with me there are some morphological differences with 'Leprosa' though they are probably not of taxonomic importance.

Back To
Uncle Derek Says Index


http://fcbs.org/